I agree with everyone above, save for the Crafting Mechanics. I think that can be left aside, UNLESS we can do something like 'flavor', like crafting custom items to give to other, with said items having the 'tags' you or the person who crafted it owns. But honestly, I'm not sure how feasible it would be to do that, and I think you can already do it through flavor (granted, this would make it more 'official').
Anyway, for my wishlist:
- More Official quests, even if they are 'generic' so people fill the blanks. Like 'save someone' or 'defeat X goblins', just to have small prompts that people can use to hop into combat, learn mechanics or even just have an 'excuse' or a 'prompt' to play together. It could even have some rotation. And of course, give incentive for DMs and even normal members to make more quests for people to use.
- Regarding the Blessing of Dedication, I propose it to not be just a mark with a Roman number, it ends up being too specific, and honestly just don't fit to some characters. Instead, I think it could be literally any mark the player want. It could be a scar, it could be a glowing rune on the body, it could be a different eye color that shimmers when reflecting on the moon, even a different type of pupil (a la Sharingan or Rinnegan), it could a hair bang that billows like flames- Essentially 'unique' physical traits that represent the Blessing, and give an 'official' unique feature to the character. And these features either intensifies, or add more depending on the 'rank'. The mark could even act up when another one of the same rank is nearby. I think it would be a more fun approach.
- Official rewards for DM Challenges. I know, it is complicated because of how DM Challenges can be different from Events, but I think it could still exist, even if it is very inferior to the usual reward of an Event. Currently, the only official reward you may end up getting in a DM Challenge is the MP/GP you get from the posts, and the nat100, nat1, nat101, nat200, nat11 achievements (which two are rare to happen, and three are borderline impossible).
- Tags, Primons, Curios, and Titles that can be bought by MP and GP. I kinda miss that. It doesn't even need to be of high rarity, but I think it would be nice to have them back. Like, at least leave the ones of low rarity to be purcheable with MP and GP, it is extra currency dump too~
- Create a subforum/space for people to set up Player Groups threads, or even displaying a 'workshop' they may have, or a player-created location like a restaurant or anything. Such as the one I have in LFG (Buddynauts). I know the LFG is there, but I think it gets too cramped, and besides, I feel like the LFG is a bit more for immediate stuff, rather than a group creation and everything.
- Also a bit of nitpick, but honestly the 'you die when you log off/is disconnected in combat' thing is a bit eh. Is it possible to change it for the IG character to simply drop limp and unconscious until the player either log in back, or die by external force, or the combat ends? Or would it ruin or break the Lore? I think it could even make for interesting situations.